On her blog, well-known tarot author Mary K. Greer announced a major new discovery of original tarot paintings from A. E. Waite’s esoteric tarot. It was reported that “Tali Goodwin of Tarot Professionals and the blog Tarot Speakeasy, through extensive research, has discovered the ORIGINAL Waite-Trinick images that comprised a tarot deck conceptualized by A.E. Waite for the private use of members of his Fellowship of the Rosy Cross.” You can find the entire intriguing  post here:


When the Golden Dawn split apart in 1903, Waite became the head of what had been Isis-Urania Temple and it became “The Holy Order of the G:.D:. under the Obedience of the Independent and Rectified Rite.” In 1915 he closed down the Rite and established the Fellowship of the Rosy Cross (the FRC). The focus of the FRC was on mysticism rather than magic.


Waite’s collaboration with artist Pamela Colman-Smith, published in 1910 as the Rider–Waite Tarot, is without a doubt the single most popular tarot deck in the world today. However, Waite produced that deck for the general public. Waite’s esoteric tarot deck, called “The Great Symbols of the Paths” contained only the tarot trumps. The images were painted by John Brahms Trinick, an Australian artist who was also a member of the FRC. Trinick was an accomplished Art Nouveau illustrator in watercolor, pencil, pastel and crayon, and a collection of his watercolour copies of European stained glass windows can be seen at the Victoria and Albert Museum.


These were not cards for divination, but cards purely for meditation and ritual work within the FRC. The original color paintings, which we saw at the London headquarters of the FRC in 2005, were all framed and used, as they still are used today, in the ceremonies of the FRC. I have to state for the record that members of the FRC to whom I have spoken are not at all happy with the publication of their ritual cards. In their words: “we condemn absolutely the publication, reproduction and indiscriminate use of these sacred symbols, and look upon those who initiate such publication and reproduction as persons who utterly lack integrity and bring shame upon their esoteric communities.”


Readers have no doubt read the brief descriptions of two of the cards in the Adeptus Major Ceremony of Waite’s Independent and Rectified Rite, published in The Complete Golden Dawn System of Magic by Israel Regardie (Volume Seven, page 140-141), but wrongly attributed to the ceremonies of the FRC. No images of the cards used by the I&R Rite seem to have survived, nor do we know who drew these images, but the descriptions printed by Regardie indicate the way in which Waite was perceiving the symbolism of the tarot trumps. When Trinick produced the “Great Symbols of the Paths” for Waite, significant changes were made, to reflect the changes in the rituals – changes that emphasized their Christian nature and removed all reference to Egyptian symbolism.  Regardie gives what Waite wrote in 1910, for he had never seen the rituals of the FRC:


“The Candidate now sees the diagram of the Hanged Man, with a Rainbow above, and the head of the Giant below.)


“Chief: […] “The symbolism with which we are here dealing also recalls the Apocalyptic figure of the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world, and in correspondence with previous explanations, it indicates that the palmary misfortune of the universe, which is exoterically called the Fall of Man, exercised a species of incomprehensible compulsion upon the Divine Nature, so that the scheme of what is familiar to everyone under the name of redemption comes before us in a certain manner as an eternal necessity and as a consequence of the free will rather of man than of God. The importance which has been attached throughout the Grades of our two Orders to Egyptian symbolism should also remind us that Mem, through the sacrifice of Christ , has analogy with the legend of the dead Osiris, one of whose appellations was the shipwrecked or drowned Mariner, even as this terrible Key, which you see now in its true form, represents a drowned giant.”


“The 23rd Key of the Tarot is referred, as you are aware, to the Elemental sign of Water, and in this diagram the drowned giant is depicted reposing on the rocky bed of the ocean with the rainbow at his feet, corresponding to that which has been sunk below the phenomenal world by a sacrifice eternally preordained, which, in one of its aspects at least, is the necessary limitation suffered by the Divine Nature in the act of becoming manifest. The Divine, in a word, is drowned in the waters of natural life; and that which in this respect obtains in the external world, obtains also for humanity, wherein the Divine Spark, beyond all plummets of the sense, all reach of the logical understanding, is immersed in the waters of the material existence. In both cases, the symbol with which we are dealing corresponds to the legend of our Founder, sleeping in the centre of the Tomb, which is encircled by the Rainbow, as in the Sanctuary of Israel there was the abiding Presence of the Shekinah. We must remember, moreover, that the ocean of phenomenal life supports on its surface the mystical Ark of Noah, which, in one of its aspects, is the Vessel of Correspondences, wherein the types of all things were collected from the wreckage of the old initiations for transmission through a new era. In another sense, which is intimately connected with the first, the Ark is the body of man, the ship of humanity, poised on the waters of the world which conceal the divine within them. It is man, collective and individual, man in possession of his senses and also enclosed by his senses. There is that within him which, during this his time of probation is put to sleep as deeply as the symbolical Giant. His originally great nature is restricted in the body after the manner of God in creation. There is yet another aspect in which we may regard the Ark, for by many issues the great symbols open upon the Infinite which they show forth, though it is after the manner of a reversed glass minutely. It is that namely, which for a time suspends the soul’s communication with the external that she may receive the influx of the Divine. It is the house of deep contemplation, of fixed, well-directed thought, by which our exit is found for a time, even from thought itself, to the world of true experience. The ceremony of the 6-5 Grade symbolises this indrawn state, in which connection I would ask you to remember that in the roof of the Ark of old there was a window through which the Dove passed and repassed, now in frustrated flight, because many wings are beaters at the Golden Gates; now bearing the olive-branch of peace which for us signifies the suspension of the life of the senses. But, in fine, there came an hour when the dove returned no more, because the aspiration and outreaching of the soul at length attains its term. Beloved brother, we have dwelt at great length upon the import of certain symbols, for albeit the work of detachment may operate scarcely less in suspension from the world, yet it is through many types that we pass ultimately behind the veils.”


I first saw these cards by Trinick (“The Great Symbols of the Paths”) when author and historian R.A. Gilbert gave a complete slide lecture on them at the 1998 International Golden Dawn Conference in Bayonne, NJ. With the owner’s permission, I have been giving a slide lecture presentation of some of these cards (both black-and-white and color versions) as well as other Pre-Golden Dawn Tarot images, since 2006.  For those who are interested, I plan on giving this same tarot lecture (“Images of Initiation: The Hermetic Tarot”) at Pantheacon 2012.


It would certainly be intriguing to discover whether Trinick produced a second set of original watercolor paintings in addition to the ones owned by the FRC. If so, this discovery is truly a breakthrough in the history of post-Golden-Dawn tarot images. I can’t wait to see them!



Donald Michael Kraig · September 19, 2011 at 7:28 pm

You're going to be at PantheaCon! That's fantastic. I plan on being there, too. I look forward to seeing you and Chic.

Tabatha · September 20, 2011 at 1:22 pm

Looking forward to it!

Anonymous · October 14, 2011 at 9:35 pm

There's an extended discussion of this project (and questions about the images, their relation to those in London, etc. with your blog cited) at Aeclectic Tarot in the History forum, section on the Rider-Waite-Smith deck.

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *